Experimental B&W

 
Paul Roark is an independent B & W photographer and printer. He is the architect of the MIS black and White inks. His knowledge of the B&W process is extraordinary. We highly regard his methods and opinions. He is not an employee of MIS Associates Inc. His opinions and recommendations are not to be construed as MIS policy. For more information about Paul, his work and his black and white discoveries, visit his website.. www.paulroark.com
 
These are some of the experimental ideas Paul has for Black and White Inks. Here you will be able to purchase some of his latest developments before they appear on our site. These products are sold without warranty or any promise of performance. They are strictly experimental. Use at your own risk.
 
Black Only Printing on R800 or R1800
100% pure carbon printing becomes a reality with the R800/R1800 printers by combining the 1.5 picoliter printhead technology available in the Epson R800/R1800 with the high Dmax and archivability of Inksupply.com Eboni Black ink. The results yield high resolution Black Only (BO) prints that will last more than a lifetime. No color pigments are used to make the print. The 3 Eboni black inks in the positions specified make this possible.
R1800 With UTBO Inks

The new Multi-Channel 100% Carbon ink for the R800/R1800 printers is a unique solution that will allow the printer to retain all but two of the non black cartridge positions. By changing only the Photo Black and Gloss Optimizer cartridges the printer is still capable of producing high quality color images on matte papers using only the Epson driver in addition to the gallery quality carbon black only output. This inkset is meant for matte papers only.

For more information or to purchase the cartridges, click here.

 
R2400 With MIS K4 Inks -


R2400 With MIS K4 Inks
For making gallery quality Black & White prints, use the Epson R2400 printer with MIS K4 inks, with a pure light-carbon ink in the yellow position to significantly reduce the amount of color used. Silver print quality can be produced with this set up when using Museo Silver Rag paper.
The Epson K3 color inks with LK and LLK will make a nice looking B&W print, however, a significant amount of color ink is used. The, non carbon, color K3 inks will fade faster than the pure carbon MIS black inks. Thus, the K3 B&W prints will not have sufficient fade resistance. The K3 yellow inks are 70 year (Wilhelm years) at best, where the pure carbon MIS black inks are 200+ year inks.

Paul has solved this problem by putting a MIS EZ Warm cartridge in the R2400 yellow position. The EZW cart contains a pure light-carbon ink. This eliminates all the Epson yellow ink from the print and reduces the use of cyan and magenta as well. The prints look even better with this set up, plus the fade resistance is extended out way beyond the Epson inks.

Roy Harrington (Quadtone Rip) writes...... "The substitution of a pure light-carbon ink for the yellow is the most ingenious idea. It single-handedly eliminates the yellow pigments and minimizes the cyan and magenta pigments..."

To do this right, the MIS LK and LLK inks should be used in place of the Epson inks. Purchase these three cartridges and give it a try.

Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
EZW-T0444-Y EZ Warm Yellow
Cart-Prefilled
Pure Light-Carbon Ink for R2400 Yellow Position $10.95
K4-T0597-SLC K4 Light Black
Cart-Prefilled
K4 Light Black Cart for R2400 prefilled with MIS LK ink $10.95
K4-T0599-SLC K4 Light Light Black
Cart-Prefilled
K4 Light Light Black Cart for R2400 prefilled with MIS LLK ink $10.95
If you are already using the MIS K4 Color inks, just get the EZW-T0424-Y cartridge. The K4 cartridges are on the MIS Epson Cartrdige page, click here.

 
UT-3D Inks Released -

Paul is always on a mission to improve the B&W printing process and the quality of the prints. So this is what he has been working on lately. If you read the B&W forum, you will already be aware of this.

Now that Epson has introduced the K3 inks (K3 = Black, Light-Black, & Light-Light Black), many folks are printing nice looking B&W prints with these K3 Epson color inks.

This is fine with us, because we sell our Epson K3 equivalent inks (MIS-K4) and they work as well or better than the Epson inks. However, it is not fine with Paul. Paul has tested the K3 inks and has found that they fade significantly faster than carbon based MIS Ultratone ink. This is, in part, because there are a lot of color dots on the B&W prints made with the Epson K3 inks. Color ink has much less fade resistance than carbon ink. So, the colors start to fade early.

Additionally, the "Advanced B&W" mode of the K3 printers does not give one the ability to profile or fine tune the tones of the print from highlights to shadows. It is not "color managed" such that the prints will be matched to the relative densities that are displayed on the monitor. And, of course, the K3 printers and inks are expensive.

So, Paul has developed an inkset that will run in many Epson 6 and 7 ink printers and gives B&W printers the fade resistance, control, and good monitor grayscale matching that the K3 printers lack.

Why call it 3D? Well, the answer to this is a little more complicated than just picking a name out of the air. The three dimensional CIE LAB color space was utilized in the development of these inks, and the carbon pigments are from our Ultratone collection, so the name UT-3D is appropriate.

This new inkset takes the UT1, UT2 and UT7 concept of variable tone and adds a new dimension. With the previous inksets the primary variability was between warm and cool, mostly using a cool single toner to pull the naturally warm carbon ink between carbon warm and neutral along what is roughly the Lab b* (yellow-blue) axis This gave much more control than a monotone inkset, but still papers would print with different degrees of red or green -- which is called the Lab a* axis. The UT-3D inkset adds variability along this axis also -- but all limited to the tones that traditional B&W printers have used for years.

In addition to providing a higher degree of control in achieving a B&W print with consistent color, or split toning where desired, the workflow is also taking advantage of ICCs to control printing as opposed to Photoshop curves. Thanks to Roy Harrington’s (http://harrington.com/index.shtml) "QTR-Create-ICC" program, these can be made by users. This allows relatively easy "linearizing" of printing systems (making the grayscale ramp smooth), including for new papers as they are released. This approach also has the advantage of matching the prints to the monitor.

After considerable beta testing and adjustments, we are ready to release the ink for sale, in bulk only for the time being. Click this button to learn more about the process and to order ink.

 
Technical Tips from Paul -
On Paul's Information Index page he has some very helpful technical tips and information on how to use MIS B&W inks.

Paul's site contains all the adjustment curves and workflows for the MIS B&W inks. There is a lot of information on his site, it is worth reading. (www.paulroark.com)

Dirk Hobman (who learned from Paul) also explains how to make curves for the MIS UltraTone B&W inks. Plus he offers a couple of graphic forms for keeping track of the data that is gathered in the process. To read his article on B&W curve making, download this file... hobman.zip.

 
PKN - Ultratone Photo Black Neutral -
Paul has discovered that, by adding some archival blue pigments to the Ultratone Photo Black ink, he can achieve a significantly higher Dmax on gloss and semi-gloss papers. The addition of the blue has only minor effects on the fade resistance of the ink. As with all Ultratone inks, no dyes are added.

This neutral-cool black ink allows one to make good black only - glossy prints in, for example, a 2200, while leaving MIS UC-equivalent color pigments in the printer. The warm, brown tone that was previously associated with black only printing is gone. Now the prints can look very much like traditional black and white silver prints. The black ink only printing also is relatively free from the "bronzing" that occurs with most glossy pigment printing.

While PKN has a higher Dmax on matte paper than the warm PK inks, it is still not a substitute for Eboni matte black.

If you are interested in trying this, we are making it available in bulk. Click on the Buy link below.


Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
UTPKN-4 Bulk Ink 4 oz Bottle of PKN $18.00



Cartridges for Black Only Printing with PKN -
Paul says the PKN does a very nice job of making gloss or semi-gloss prints without the assistance from the other inks. It has been done on the 1280, 2200 and 4000 printers. More to be tested in future.

So, we are making the PKN available in cartridges for the 1280, 2200, 7600 and 4000 printers. Please let us know how your results turn out. Just set your printer to black only, and print using the Epson driver. There are no curves or special workflow.

The beauty of Black Only Printing is that the printer can now print both black&white and color.

Like all the products on this page, there is no guarantee or promise of performance, it is strictly experimental.


Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
PKN-T0341 2200 Photo Black
Cart-Prefilled
Photo Black Cart for 2200 prefilled with PKN ink $10.95
PKN-T007 1280 Black
Cart-Prefilled
T007 Black Cart for 1280 prefilled with PKN ink $22.08
PKN-T5431 7600/4000 Black Cart-Prefilled Photo Black Cart for 7600/4000 prefilled with PKN ink $49.95





UT2 With GLOP -
Paul has been experimenting with GLOP (Gloss Optimizer). By putting GLOP in the yellow position of a UT2 cartridge (T009 for 1280) he has been able to make some very nice gloss and semi-gloss prints.

They are better than what the standard UT2 inks can produce, unless those prints are sprayed with PremierArt Print Shield after drying thoroughly. While such sprays offer more protection to the print, the extra step and noxious fumes can now be avoided.

The GLOP takes the place of the spray and is automatically applied while one prints. On the better glossy and Semigloss papers it largely eliminates the bronzing.

Paul has made curves for the 1280 that must be used to distribute the Glop properly. Download the 1280 Glop curves here or they are available on Paul's Website.

The curves are made for specific papers, they are not generic curves. Paper recommendations are included with the curve documentation.

The Eboni black is what should be in the black position. Paul says that using Photo Black does not give better Dmax. So all the curves are written for Eboni. Plus with Eboni installed, glossy and matte prints can be made without changing the black cartridge.


Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
GLP-T009-UT2 5 Shade B&W
Cart-Prefilled
UT2 T009 CART WITH GLOP IN YEL POS $32.76
ARC-T007-UTK Black Cart UT2 T007 BLACK CART - EBONI $22.08
GLP-T0344-Y 2200 GLOP Cart Yellow Cart for 2200 Prefilled with GLOP $11.00

GLOP for 2200 -
If you are not making sepia toned prints with UT7 Black & White Inks, then you can put a yellow 2200 cart filled with GLOP into the yellow position of your 2200. This will help reduce bronzing and surface effects when making glossy prints. Roark has some curves for this set up on his website www.paulroark.com.

It is available for purchase above.


GLOP In Bulk Available
If you wish to fill your own cartridge or install GLOP on a bulk feed system (CFS), we are making it available in bulk. See below.
Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
ESCR800-2-OPT GLOP GLOSS OPTIMIZER 2 OZ BOTTLE $12.00
ESCR800-4-OPT GLOP GLOSS OPTIMIZER 4 OZ BOTTLE $18.00
ESCR800-PT-OPT GLOP GLOSS OPTIMIZER PINT BOTTLE $50.00
ESCR800GL-OPT GLOP GLOSS OPTIMIZER GALLON BOTTLE $384.00


Creating a Black & White Inkset -     (Written by MIS Staff)
The black archival pigmented ink diffuses light very efficiently. Another way to say this is to say that, "black dominates". A few drops of black ink in a pint of clear base stock will turn the entire pint black.

See the chart below. This shows the relationship between the percent of black ink in the mixture vs the darkness or percent black you would see on a gradient or grayscale. Note that it does not take much black ink to run the darkness up into the 80% plus region. The curve shown is typical, but actual curves for a specific paper will vary. Each paper has its own curve shape. This curve can be used as a starting point. You can construct a curve for your paper using a batch of inks with different black percentages, by swabbing1 the different percentages on the paper and then scanning it with a flatbed scanner. Use the eyedropper in Photoshop to determine the grayscale percentages.

To achieve 100% on the grayscale it would theoretically take 100% black ink in the mixture. But from a practical point of view, the 100% grayscale is almost reached when the mixture contains 25% black ink. The final few hundredths of a percent on the grayscale require much more black to be added, until the black ink is at 100%.

The good news is, that in this range the inks are linear. So calculation of how much black to add is a simple ratio and proportion calculation.

 
Making Shades of Gray with Color Tints -
Four color inkjet printers need a light shade of gray, a medium shade, a dark shade and black to produce a good gray scale. You can pick these numbers off the vertical scale on the above chart. Then determine the percent of black ink in the mixture required to achieve these grayscale percentages. Use the following formula to determine how much black to add to the base stock.

K = P/(1-P) x Base

For example, if you need a 60% grayscale ink, then you need a 2% black mixture. Using 30 cc of Base you want make a 2% black mixture, then the amount of black to add is K=[.02/.98]x30 = 0.61 cc black. So the total is 30.61 cc and the percent black is .61/30.61 = 2% and the resulting grayscale should be close to 60%.

Now add the tint. For a blue tint, mix photo cyan and photo magenta in equal parts. Add base stock until you get the shade of blue desired. Add this blue mixture to the 2% black mixture in steps of 10%. Swab the resulting mixture to see if it meets your requirements. If you started with a 30 cc amount of your black ink, then add 3 cc of the blue, then swab test it. If it is too weak, add another 3 cc and swab test again. Keep on adding the blue in 3 cc steps until you get the look you need.

Swab Testing1 -
Use a cotton swab or Q-Tip, dip it in the ink and paint a 2 inch square on the paper you will be printing on. You must wait for it to dry before passing judgement. Swabbing is not very accurate. If it turns out to be too dark, then you went too far. The swab squares will be darker than what is printed by the printer. When you think you have it right, load the ink in a cartridge and give it a test. Use a Metering Rod instead of a swab for more accuracy (see note 1).

Testing With a 4 Color Printer -
Paul Roark has worked out a Photoshop curve that separates the inks on a grayscale. In other words, when you print a 21 step grayscale with this special curve, the ink from each chamber will be easily identified and can be measured for density. This is very significant, because the printer tends to print much lighter than swabbing.


The lower image is what the grayscale looks like after the image is converted to RGB and the curve is applied. The zones marked C,M,Y,K are the pure inks from each chamber in the cartridge. Normally, this is very difficult to achieve, because the Epson print driver is mixing and blending inks from more than one chamber to achieve the requested colors. But with Roark's curve, this is a breeze. Click here to download a zip file containing the grayscale image and the color curve. Using this method takes the experimental or human error out of the swabbing process.

The Toner Concept -
If you have tried the MIS VM-QUAD inks, you will know that in the yellow position the ink is a light blue-gray tint. This blue ink is know as the "toner" ink. Using the Roark workflow and curves for the VM-Quad inks, will produce a warm, medium warm, neutral or cool, black and white print. These Roark curves bring in different amounts of toner to add coolness to the print. If you put a yellow shade of ink in the toner position (yellow chamber) you can make a sepia looking print. The Roark curves will still work to give you 4 degrees or amounts of yellow toner, depending on which curve you use. The toner ink must have the same density as the original VM1 toner, but it can be ANY COLOR you wish it to be. This opens the door for all kinds of different looks, from sepia, cool, magenta, green, or literally any tone you want.

Record Keeping -
Keeping records of your percentages and the swab results is vital. You can cut down on the number of iterations needed by using the data from past trials. If you make one batch too light and another too dark, then you can use your data to calculate how to make the third batch. Without the record of what you did to make the previous batches you will be lost and you may never be able to make the desired shade or tint or if you do you will not be able to reproduce it again. So keep good records.

Other Shades and Tints -
If you want a warmer look, add yellow to your inks. If you want a cool look in the darker shades and a warm look in the shadows, add blue to the darkest ink and yellow to the lightest ink. The possibilities are endless. Don't assume your special ink mixtures and tints will translate across several papers. Each different paper may give you surprise results. Papers and the coatings on them have a major impact on colors and densities.

Equipment Recommendations -
Some 10 cc syringes and needles are almost a necessity. One or more for each color is a good idea. Measuring ink using a syringe is not very accurate. We recommend getting a small electronic gram scale. Many office supply stores sell them for postage metering. They are also available from scientific supply houses and in some health food stores for measuring food quantities. If you can get one that displays a tenth of a gram, then this is best. In addition to the syringes, needles and gram scale you will need a good number of sample bottles. The one ounce bottles are ideal for making ink samples. When you are ready to make a larger batch, use the four ounce or pint bottles. A box of Q-Tips and a notebook to record your results in are mandatory.

Making Curves -
This is the hard part. You will need a copy of Photoshop and a decent scanner. If you have color management software, make sure your monitor, scanner and printer are all profiled together. This is not mandatory, but it sure helps. Monaco EZcolor 2 or Praxisoft WiziWYG will do this job.

The perfect Photoshop curve will give you even 5% steps from 0% to 100% for your inkset. Load the inks into a cartridge and print a grayscale. You can make your own, or use ours. Click here to download the file. Just right click on the image and save it to your hard drive. Check the RGB numbers using the Photoshop eyedropper tool. RGB# = 255 x (1.00-P) Where P is the percent value on the grayscale. This is the basic tool needed for making curves.

To construct a curve, change the grayscale test pattern to the RGB mode. Then go to Image-Adjust-Curves. Modify the Red, Green and Blue curves until you can print a perfect grayscale test pattern with the curve applied. In other words, change the Red curve, Blue curve and Green curve. Click OK, your test image will now have color. Print the image, then scan it. After it is scanned, use the Photoshop eyedropper tool and check the percentage steps against the master grayscale you created above. After studying the errors, go back and adjust the R, G, and B curves and print again. Scan it and check it. It normally takes 7 or 8 iterations to get a good curve for a new inkset. This is how Roark and others have made the curves on our Workflow page. You could start your process by using one of their curves that gives you close to a perfect grayscale.

For more insight on making Photoshop curves, read Dirk Hobman's article on B&W curve making, download this file... hobman.zip.

  Note (1) - Swabbing is not very scientific. The variance in the results is high. In other words, if you swab the ink 5 times you will get 5 different results.

An alternate to swab testing is to use a Metering Rod. A metering rod, is a steel rod wound with small diameter wire. A blob of ink is placed on a piece of paper and the rod is used to spread the ink across the paper. Because of the uniform space between the tightly wound wire, the ink gets spread on the paper in a uniform thickness. Metering Rods can be purchased from Diversified Enterprises.

A better method than swabbing or using a metering rod, is to use a printer that has a black cartridge. Set the printer for black only printing. Then load a virgin empty cart with the black ink you are testing. Print a one inch square using 720 dpi or high settings. Wait for the square to dry, then measure the density with a Densitometer or Spectrophotometer. We use an X-Rite SwatchBook Spectrophotometer (cost $1000 apporx). This is a much better method than swabbing and scanning. But not all of us can afford the time and the cost of the density measuring device. The GretagMacbeth Eye-One is the most popular instrument for making curves and profiles.


We hope this helps you get started. The process is a learning experience. We will be glad to post anything you learn that you would like to share with others. Just drop us an email. You will be surprised at the results you can achieve in a short period of time. Good Luck on creating the perfect black ink set.

Below we offer the clear Base Stock for Blending Black & White inks. Do not use Eboni as the Black Ink for blending. Original Archival Black, 7600 Light Black, or 7600 Photo Black are the acceptable black inks for blending. Visit the Pigment Inks page to purchase a black ink or a color ink for toning.

If you think this is a daunting project, you are probably right. Paul Roark has spent thousands of hours doing this type of work. His ink blends are the best. There really is no need to recreate his work, he has done a fantastic job of blending black & white inksets. Try our EZN, UT, UT2, UT7, UTFS and UTFSN inksets. You will be amazed at the results you can get. Find your printer and inkset in the charts on the Black & White page. This gives you all the products, papers, and workflows needed to product Gallery quality prints.


Buy MIS Part No. Type D e s c r i p t i o n Price
ESC-BASE-4-UC Clear Base 4 oz Bottle of Clear Base Stock $ 8.00
ESC-BASE-PT-UC Clear Base Pint Bottle of Clear Base Stock $24.00
ESC-BASE-GL-UC Clear Base Gallon Bottle of Clear Base Stock $85.00
ESCARC-PT-K Archival Black Pint Bottle of Original Archival Black $48.00
ESC7600-PT-LK Light Black Pint Bottle of 7600 Light Black $50.00
ESC7600-PT-PK Photo Black Pint Bottle of 7600 Photo Black $50.00
All of the above blacks are pure carbon pigment black ink with extreme fade resistance.
Clear Base Stock is cleaning fluid or ink without color. It has ammonia in it for cleaning, and no alcohols. It will dissolve clogs if you get it in the print head and let it stay there for a few days. You can print with it to purge out other inks. In B&W applications, it is used to dilute the black inks into lighter shades of gray.

For soaking the parking pad, dilute base stock with distilled water 50/50. This lowers the viscosity and allows the fluid to be wicked up into the nozzles when the print head is parked. This is MIS-FLUID (nozzle fluid). It will not print properly, but great for wicking up into nozzles.



We will be adding more of Paul's discoveries as they become available.


Return

	

Home Page Shopping Cart Contents Find products the easy way Your Account Site Map
© Copyright 2008 MIS Associates Inc. All Rights Reserved.
[ Black and White  |  Carts  |  Inks  |  CFS  |  Kits  |  Paper  |  Printers  |  Contact Us  |  eSupport ]